File photo
In response to growing confusion and concern circulating online regarding the future of Orchard Lake and its aging dam, Botetourt County officials have released a public statement to set the record straight on their social media outlets. The county emphasized that recent developments stem from state-level safety mandates – not local decisions – and clarified its limited role in what remains primarily a private matter.
The Orchard Lake Dam, constructed in the early 1900s, was privately owned for over a century. However, a recent survey revealed that a portion of the dam sits on a parcel acquired by Botetourt County in 1995, effectively making the county a co-owner by default. This discovery coincides with updated requirements from the Virginia Department of Conservation and Recreation (DCR), which now mandate that the dam be either brought into compliance with modern safety regulations or be breached and drained.
“This is a state-level requirement, not a decision made by Botetourt County,” the statement read.
In 2022, DCR notified the dam’s private owners of the new mandates, which include engineering inspections, emergency action plans, and ongoing vegetation control. After assessing the financial burden, the private owners concluded they could not afford the upgrades. Since Botetourt County owns only a small adjacent parcel, it is not solely responsible for the dam’s future, but it does share some responsibility.
To assist the property owners, county staff supported an application for a DCR grant that would cover up to 50% of the planning and design costs to safely breach the dam. On May 27, the Board of Supervisors voted to match those funds if the grant is awarded. Importantly, no physical work has been authorized at this time.
Two public meetings with surrounding property owners were held in 2023. Despite exploring options – including repairing the dam, reducing its height, or full removal – no consensus emerged on funding repairs or long-term maintenance. The group ultimately opted to pursue the breach option due to liability concerns and financial constraints.
“The county is not driving this process,” the update clarified. “It is helping where it can to ensure safe, informed, and responsible steps are taken.”
County officials urge residents to seek accurate information and avoid speculation. For further details and historical context, citizens are encouraged to visit www.bocofacts4u.com.
As the situation evolves, Botetourt County pledged to continue working transparently with the affected property owners and the state to reach a resolution that prioritizes both safety and public understanding.
~ Fincastle Herald staff report
